mobil gargoyle
Techdirt: When Mobile Phones (Could, Maybe If It Benefits Us) Maim
Home
The Techdirt Insight Community
The Techdirt Blog
Corporate Intelligence
About Techdirt
Contact Us
Main
Submit a Story
Advertise With Us
Send Us Feedback
Subscribe To Newsletter
Polls
Techdirt Wireless
Your Preferences
From the Techdirt Blog...
<< The Aftermath Of RIM-NTP: Other Patent Hoarders Emboldened
| Suing Google Because Your Google Site Ranking Sucks >>
Overhype
by Carlo Longino
Fri, Mar 17th 2006 3:42pm
Share This
Permalink.
When Mobile Phones (Could, Maybe If It Benefits Us) Maim
from the bias?-what's-that? dept
A stunning new piece of research from the UK says that 78% of mobile phone users aged 16-24 "reported backache, neckache and headaches". What's stunning aren't the results, after all, everybody gets headaches once in a while, but rather the way the survey's being used. Apparently some unnamed experts say all that can be caused by "holding your mobile phone between your ear and neck while trying to do other tasks simultaneously". Did we mention the research was sponsored by a company that makes hands-free headsets? Notice they don't say the people who answered the survey didn't say that holding their phone in such a way caused them problems, they just tacked that expert bit on in the next sentence of their press release to try and indicate some causality that they probably never even tested. Biased surveys are nothing new, but this one really is scraping the bottom of the barrel. It's even got the requisite quote from a company manager saying how everything would be okay, if just every young person in Britain would buy one of their headsets. Bet they'd still get the occasional headache, though.
40 Comments
| Leave a Comment..
Reader Comments (rss)
(Flattened / Threaded)
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
by dorpus on Mar 17th, 2006 @ 4:27pm
In a class I'm taking right now, we had an MD expert on carpal tunnel syndrome give a lecture on the topic. In the 20 years and 10,000 patients that he has tested for the condition, a grand total of one patient tested positive.That hasn't stopped companies from making millions with fake "testing devices" to screen workers for the condition. Contrary to popular myth, computer work is among the least stressful occupations on wrist health. Other occupations like lumberjacks or carpentry have a far higher rate of problems, and such workers are recommended computer jobs to recover their wrist health.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
food
by Mc Donald on Mar 17th, 2006 @ 8:14pm
They should also include how much High Fructose Corn Syrup they consume. I think this i more of the cause of the headaches and migrains.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by Mahmoud on Mar 17th, 2006 @ 11:41pm
It is true that mobile phones do cause very severe brain damage over a period of 2hrs. of continous using ( talking on the mobile for 2 hours ). Although most people only use mobile phones for an average of 4 minutes per call, you still have a chance of getting severe brain damage very easily without being the user of the phone yourself. Supose you are sitting in a room in which there are 10 people sitting and about 7 of them carry moblie phones. The waves will be more concentrated and you will be likely to get brain damage faster than if you are even talking on the phone. Unfortanately, in my country there are families in which every member carries atleast 1 mobile phone, and I can link this to the number of kids who are even born handicapped or mentally disabled!!I think that headaches are nothing but the begining to whats coming next...
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by dorpus on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 12:45am
Then can you show me any respectable, peer-reviewed medical studies that support this notion? (I do not mean small studies done in Finland, Jordan, or those kind of countries.)
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by A Funny Guy / The Poison Pen on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 2:49am
Are you stark raving mad....No I've changed my mind......This rubbish is not worth a response from me
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by NOCcer on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 5:20am
Most any phone conversation that lasts two hours causes brain damage from the sheer stupidity of the content of that call.I can't count how many times (oh crap are the brain cells dying in that large a quantity??) I've walked out of a 2+ hour conference call and had severe headaches.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by ehrichweiss on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 7:54am
They couldn't even cook an egg with 2 cell phones 1 inch away from the egg...so brain damage isn't gonna happen in 2 hours unless it's because you were smoking crack while on the phone.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
aches/pains
by Patrick Miltner on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 8:14am
Last winter I almost always carried my cell phone in the leg pocket of my cargo pants. Towards the end of spring, I was starting to get muscle twitching right in the region where my cell phone was resting against my leg. Lo and behold, now that I don't carry it on my body, the twitching has stopped. The same goes for my father - He stopped carrying his phone on his belt because he was getting little spasms around his waistline. Once he put the phone in his briefcase during the work day, it stopped. There's something to be said for mobile phones causing strange sensations, but as far as brain damage and chronic headaches go, I think that's a little exaggerated.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: aches/pains
by Brandy on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 10:40am
Was the twitching from the cell phone...or from something constantly vibrating against your leg? If you carried a vibrator around instead for a couple months I'm pretty sure the same thing would happen.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by Saint Jerome on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 11:58am
Are you kidding me? The "waves" or radiation from phones DO NOT CAUSE BRAIN DAMAGE. That has been pretty well established. It is much more dangerous to stand under power lines and we're pretty much under them 24/7, and it has still never even been proven that they cause serious problems.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by Billy on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 1:24pm
Wow, that has to be the most addlepated notion I've ever heard. I wonder what other rediculious things exist in your world. Thank you sir for opening your mouth and removing all doubt.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: aches/pains
by Gargoyle on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 7:36pm
The same thing happened to me!! I had to quit wearing cargo pants because I carry things around in the pockets. Like screwdrivers, cable testers... all manner of things. Except my cel phone. I carry it in it's belt-holster.I quit wearing cargo pants, and guess what? My muscle aches went away. It's not the freakin' celphone. It's having something banging on your leg all day that makes it hurt. Or, it could be the cotton. Wait, I forgot, I wear 501's now. They're cotton too. Never mind.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
by HamDude on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 7:46pm
Oh wow, if 2+ hours on a cell phone would cause severe brain damage, I would be dead. Good thing that your just a fucking idiot who spews shit out of his mouth.So, I use my cell phone at night so I don't wake anybody else up in the house when someone wants to call me, and my phone calls usually last alot longer then 2 hours, and I have almost talked all night before.Honestly if there was any truth behind that at all, then according to you my brain would have leaked out of my ear and I would have licked up the puddle of my own liquified brain thinking it was strawberry syrup.Anyone who beleives this prick, should be shot, because your like the rabbit that jumped in front of my tire the other day.One rabbit set on the side of the road, and the other one jumped right in front of my tire, thats what I call natural selection.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by Mahmoud on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 8:50pm
plz visit this linkthere are alot of other things i read but this is just a more trusted 1.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
by Mahmoud on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 8:52pm
http://www.ehn.clara.net/mobilephones.html
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by anon on Mar 18th, 2006 @ 11:56pm
If I published an article about how being on the internet can give you diabetes, would you rush out and tell people that it must be true?Seriously, unless you're getting it from a medical journal that actually has some sort of peer review (I don't trust network news....they usually only tell the part of the story that's interesting while leaving out the important things), don't believe it. Just because someone has a website doesn't make them an authority on anything.Of coarse, just because I'm posting on TechDirt doesn't make me an authority on anything either. Keep believing that cell phones cause brain damage, the Olympic Torch virus will reprogram your DVD player and microwave, and that if you don't send this letter than Jebus started over 2,000 years ago to 10 of your friends in the next eleven and a half seconds, personal parts of your anatomy will start rotting and falling off.The internet is a good starting point, but don't rely on it for everything. Find me an article from the NEJoM to peruse about this, and I may take you more seriously. Until then, you're just some nut who believes everything they read.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
by Clay on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 1:10am
I love people who are smart, and those who realize medical journals exist.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: Re: Mobile Phones also cause brain damage
by Mahmoud on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 1:11am
You might as will think, before deciding whether to believe it or not. I know very well that many of the articles on the internet are exaggerated, and i did not say that the internet is my only source. The internet is the connection between me and you right now, and therefore I decided that a proof from the internet is the best example becauze you will be only one click away from seeing what you are looking for.Some articles on the internet say that no serious research was made to find out about whether mobile phones are really harmful or not. So, does this mean that because they are on the internet I should not be believing them.. ONE OF THE OPINIONS HAS TO BE TRUE. I believe from many articles which I have read and even from personal experience that using a mobile phone for long time is harmful. It is in the end up to you to believe it or not to, but before blaming others for not searching in a proper media make sure you read about the other point of view. Who knows maybe it could be right afterall.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
TO DORPUS & ANON
by Mahmoud on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 1:39am
plz visit the following linkit is published in the online edition of the peer-reviewed journal Environmental Health Perspectives (EHP) http://www.ehponline.org/press/012903.html
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Sample Size
by giafly on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 5:52am
This could have been based on a telephone sample of only 168 young adults 17-24."Methodology - TNS interviewied a representative sample of 1,008 GB adults aged 16+ by telephone 2nd-4th december 2005." - webitpr. Assuming people live to an average age of 70, and the interviewers contacted them randomly, this means about of them 168 were in the range 17-24.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
by WhoNu on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 6:17am
"Can you hear me now?"
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
cell phone headaches
by Bill Butler on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 8:05am
the 16-24 y/o age group being the most prevalent ages for I-Pod use, how do they know that the head aches may not be caused but rock/hip-hop at high volumes 4-8 hours a day?
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re:
by Rob on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 8:35am
Your all stupid. Think about this for a second, the radio waves used by cell phones carry less energy than visble light. We stand in visible light all day. This also applies to people who think microwaves can cause cancer etc... I hate people.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Cell phones and damaged brains...
by Elf Ink on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 8:51am
Perhaps it's damaged brains that leads to cell phone use, instead of the other way around.At any rate, just leave the issue in the hands of the prison authorities... they can eliminate cell phones if the prisoners exhibit too much brainial deficiency.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Yeah but people don't even believe the "Can you He
by Andrew Strasser on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 11:08am
The guy wound up suing over the fact that having the phone by his head so often caused him to have cancer across the side of his head. RF has been known to cause cancer. Eveeryone knows it does and yet they still don't make you put a surgeons general warning on cell hpones that says this device could cause cancerous brain tumors. Guess it's hard to get rid of something so they try to think of innovative solutions. That would take some research though now wouldn't it.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
So Simple!!!
by Mohd on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 12:13pm
Is that what its all about.......why dont u just keep the cellphone 8 inches away from your heads by using the loudspeaker.....??or u guys already are having brain damage then its too late,you cant think of any solution....heres one....!!
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Cell phone brain damage
by Ponder on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 2:19pm
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Cell phone brain damage
by Ponder on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 2:25pm
Sorry for my miss post, hit the wrong key.Supposed reason for cell phone brain damage is the microwaves. Theses are supposed to heat up the brain. Microwave ovens have power measured in hunderds of watts. Cell phones measure microwave power in milliwatts. There is not enough power to cause brain damage. This is an outdated theory which has been disproven on humans. The trials on mice showed that phone then caused some of the mice brain damage. A human brain is larger and heats up slower. tHe mice were on the phones 24/7. Cell phones now use less power in the microwaves due to new laws in the EU and USA
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
by Jay-Z on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 3:07pm
Wish my battery lasted long enough to make a 2 hour call.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: TO DORPUS & ANON
by anon on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 9:13pm
That's a three year old article that says little more than the fact that there is a strong need for more study. There have been no human studies (many things found true in rats are not true in humans), they admit that there weren't really enough rats, and no where in the article did it talk about the follow-up study that they suggested.Where is the actual research? Where is the conclusive proof? I'm still not saying that you're wrong or that I'm right, I'm saying that the article there really doesn't have a whole lot of meat to it. It's good that they're doing the research, but, as they say in the article, there is "a strong need for further study as we all rely on cell phones more and more." Until there is more study, we won't really know the truth of the matter.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
by Anonymous Coward on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 10:41pm
You are all wrong. Cell phones aren't the problem... talking is! Consider history and it becomes apparent that talking is the cause of all problems in the world. Why can't we as a supposedly intelligent life form just shut up?
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
by Anonymous Coward on Mar 19th, 2006 @ 10:43pm
I forgot to add you are all giving me a headache. And my entire body aches from the pure stupidity. I am starting a boycott on talking. Please support the boycott and just shut up!
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
to Coward
by Mohd on Mar 20th, 2006 @ 4:47am
what u say will even cause more stupidity than ever before,,, everybody will beleive in his own stupid ideas ......its gonna be damn crazy.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Cookin' eggs....
by Suitedfists on Mar 20th, 2006 @ 8:50am
Someone had mentioned a test that was performed using 2 cells phones to try and cook an egg......Update: The hit series, Myth Busters, cracked this one wide open by trying to cook an egg which was surrounded by 100 cell phones that were all on an active call....... Final result: After the testing, the egg was just as "uncooked" as it was before the test took place.....Conclusion: Hop on a motorcycle without your helmet and hit the pavement of the highway doing 135 MPH....... There's your brain damage....... 'nough said!
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Headaches
by ergonomics on Mar 20th, 2006 @ 10:04am
Any telephone handset held between the ear and the shoulder will cause neck muscle problems that can lead to a headache, whether it is a cell phone or not.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
reply
by bill on Jun 22nd, 2006 @ 3:38am
is think this evidence is shit
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
masts
by jena on Jul 12th, 2006 @ 2:10am
masts are a good thing becuase it is not affecting us it is the mobile it self
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
mobile phone
by john on Oct 1st, 2006 @ 1:09pm
Forget research, it happen to me. mobile has given me brain damage and i am suffering with it. Com on give up my fellow human beings.thanx
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Re: aches/pains
by Matthew Edgley on Mar 8th, 2007 @ 4:57am
The exact same thing happened to me, and I am certain it is caused by the phone. I used to carry it exactly like you and I got twitching in my left quadriceps where the phone would be in my pocket. Then I put it in a container and carried it in a bag and the twitching stopped. But recently I have been using this school bag that you carry on one shoulder. I put my phone in it all the time, the material is thin and the bag usually rests under my right arm. Now I am getting the same muscle twitches in my right bicep. It is pretty bad, so I am going to use a new bag and get another container to put my phone in. There is a lot about phones that the manufacturers will not tell us and that is because if bad news surfaces then they lose lots of $$$ greedy bastards.
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
mobile phones should be banned
by TANZIM on Oct 1st, 2007 @ 1:02pm
Mobile phones shoulb be banned because they cause cardiological and neurological problems.....
(reply to this comment)
(link to this comment)
Add Your Comment
Name
Email
Get Techdirt’s Daily Email
URL
Subject
Comment
this is for spambots, do not use this
Options Plain Text HTML
Save me a cookie
Plain Text: A CRLF will be replaced by break
tag, all other allowable HTML is intact
HTML: No formatting of any kind is done without explicitly being written in
Allowed HTML Tags:
Close
Name
Email
Get Techdirt’s Daily Email
URL
Subject
Comment
this is for spambots, do not use this
Options Plain Text HTML
Save me a cookie
<< The Aftermath Of RIM-NTP: Other Patent Hoarders Emboldened
| Suing Google Because Your Google Site Ranking Sucks >>
Search the Techdirt Blog
And now, a word from our Sponsors..
Subscribe to Techdirt's Daily Email Newsletter
Techdirt's Daily Email Newsletter
Related Stories
Government-Funded Textbooks: Let's Not And Say We Did (29)
Comcast Cares -- But Only About People Like You (19)
IFPI Witness Used To Work For IFPI -- Is That Such A Big Deal? (20)
The Open Source Model Is About Organization, Not Who Signs Your Paycheck (9)
EU Tells Videogame Industry To Protect Children; Doesn't Explain From What (22)
Contact Us
Close
Social Web
E-mail
del.icio.us
Digg
Furl
Netscape
Yahoo! My Web
StumbleUpon
Google Bookmarks
Technorati
BlinkList
Newsvine
ma.gnolia
reddit
Windows Live
Tailrank
E-mail It
To Address
Your Name
Your Address
разделы
софт автошкола
ваза 2111
морозильный витрина
thuraya sg 2510
деловой разведка
мистер бин
блюдо фарфор
o2 optix
брэнд
эдас-134 аденома предст.ж-зы
protherm
кружка
решетка оцинкованный
асбест хризотиловый
дешевый холодильник
бейсболки заказ
кислород
обогащение кислородом
профессиональный фарфор
8800 gold
сбор д/полоскания горло зубной боль
инерта краска
уничтожитель
анкетирование
5440.11 (крышка)
вилатерм
срочный перевод
mobilux
компания доминике
генерация кислорода
охота бабочка
оформление свадеб
дэнас
оповещение
metrobond
концентрирование кислорода
mobilux
герб область
электропечь dimplex model elba
система видеоконференция
застежка zip-lock
рефрижератор
дэнас
бейсболки заказ
набор гинекологический
перегородка сантехкабин
структурный штукатурка
герб рф
купить каболка
шелковый ковры
залог кострома
кристофер брэнд
купить айсбест
заказать микроавтобус
цепной конвейер
доломит
мачта флагшток
трубогиб
прайс зеркало
теплогенераторы master
5004.14 (крышка)
купить ниппель
золотник 264-27-00
lida
магнитный решетка
снегоход буран
ведро шампанский
адресный база данный
тач-скрин монитор
пошив корпоративный костюм
эксимер лазер
витрина мороженый
ведро шампанский
укв радиосвязь
sky link
переработка резина
крот dr
корпоративный иностранный
антенна
барбекю
пескоструйка
управление иваново
кофе дорога
маршрутизатор
кулер процессорный
покраска аэротенк
скачать короткий нард
детский лагерь пионер
концепция совершенствование сбыта
лечение слух
домашний очаг здоровье
гравировальный бур
вымпел заказ
southpark
озонатор воздуха
купить джойстик
очистка подогреватель
кофе колониальный товар
время владимир
блюдо фарфор
рассылка база данный
плата видеозахвата
ночной очки
инвертор
билет мхат
купить чейнджер
редизайн кострома
купить аудиоплееры
выделенка
басейны intex
профессиональный видеосъемка
сдача ielts
бюро переводчик
слоеный изделие
rittal
дренаж
braas
гуп ритуал
проходить осмотр гинеколог
переработка резина
время архангельск
вызов врач
купить угольник перех
мурано
кострома коммерческий
nokia 6021 купить
проведение анкетирование
антенна бустер
купить стиральный
экг 4у
ленинградский вокзал билет
шелкография
морозильный витрина
встраиваемый вытяжка
купить яйцеварку
гайковерт электрический
фризер
фасадный покрытие
корпаративные праздник
пежо
автоподъемник
купить раструб
снегоход буран
светодиодный экран
укрепление откос
контейнерный автозаправка
беседка
neri karra кожгалантерея
купить угольник перех
красный объявление
кристофер брэнд
заказ обед
враждебный поглощение
изолента хб
mobil pegasus
ленинградский вокзал билет
мурано
детский гинеколог
толщиномер
встраиваемый вытяжка
бордюр обоев
вилатерм
винный холодильник
рассылка корреспонденция
доставка алкогольный
hi-fi
пассажирский лифт
ваза 21102
кэрролл дж. страна смеха
герб рф
сервис альфа лаваль
заказать флаг
акриловый вставка вкладыш
промывка инжектор
mobil gargoyle